Comments (52)

To leave or reply comments, please download free Podbean iOS App or Android App.

Thank you for not making the cases about you. The way some podcasters insert themselves and hover like vultures and strut like peacocks is awful. I like to know what’s going on but not at the expense of the families or the process.

1 months ago reply 0

Hang on... I’m gonna go get my magnifying glass and Sherlock hat!

3 months ago reply 0

Oof. I can’t listen to Bret and Alice. After catching them in more than a couple ”untruths” re the Adnan Syed case, they’re a no-go for me. Hope y’all had fun talking to them, though! I’ll be back next ep.

4 months ago reply 0

I love the unbiased just the facts deep dive thank you both

6 months ago reply 0

Back in the day the older phones you would need to shut it off & turn it back on in order for it to switch for daylight savings

6 months ago reply 0

we’re 39 hours in and just getting to the arrest and you’ve said that the motions are monumental in scope once we get to trial. I just don’t understand what 45 minutes of his dad saying he doesn’t know is valuable use of time discussing the case. I’m trying to stick with you, and I’m not trying to tell you how to run your podcast but you’re branching out in a lot of different directions with daybell, Idaho 4, Steven Avery, Delphi. are we ever really going to get through this trial?

6 months ago reply 0

That closing argument was highly effective. I think it completely destroyed the insanity defense. He knew exactly what he was doing.

6 months ago reply 0

how coincidental that he wakes up exactly when she arrives and ”leaves when she’s inside Steven’s trailer.” some great detective work going on.

6 months ago reply 0

who bow hunts for an hour and a half including travel time both ways including a road side conversation with your moms boyfriend? that makes absolutely no sense.

6 months ago reply 0

It wasn’t Timothy Mccoy’s body #1 was John Prestiege. Timothy is #9.

2 years ago reply 0

This one is chilling how he says on the tape Godzick dug his own grave. Gacy wasn’t even bothered by it. Sad and cruel his parents had Christmas presents waiting in the closet for him for 3 years. Dan Genty found a blond hair in the crawl space and hitting the bone.

2 years ago reply 0

I love the Gacy tapes. They are amazing. I love how it it told from different angles including the victims. I wonder how the defense decided to go after the insanity defense and not that someone else could’ve commited some of the crimes. Or how the photo receipt is considered planted evidence. How they could not test the rope around some of the victim’s necks now for epiphial cells to see if the Match the creep or other items for them. It gives you a lot to think about.

2 years ago reply 0

His demeanor is meaningless. 100%. Different people react differently. We even do upset differently. I’ve heard podcasts where similar situations occur and someone like you is questioning the sincerity of the upset, alleging potential fake rage or over the top sadness. Completely meaningless. And also not a reason to check an alibi. The reason to check the alibi is because two people are dead. No more reason needed

2 years ago reply 0